Recently Added

The apparent reversals are real cases that need answering. The distinction the tradition draws is between a doctrine unfolding what it always contained and a doctrine being contradicted — and it is a distinction with teeth.

Silent sitting, attention to the breath, a quiet mind — Catholic contemplative prayer and secular mindfulness can look identical from the outside. What actually distinguishes them isn't technique but what the practice is for.

Reports of tunnels of light and encounters with deceased relatives are often taken as vindicating an afterlife in general. Whether they vindicate the specifically Catholic account of death and judgment is a much narrower question.

The synodal process has revived a very old question in a new form: how far does the Church's structure of authority actually extend, and what, precisely, is it capable of changing?

In 2018, the Catechism began calling the death penalty 'inadmissible.' Whether that's a legitimate development of doctrine or a genuine reversal is one of the sharpest live disputes in Catholic moral theology today.

Both technologies promise real goods — a child for an infertile couple, a cure for an inherited disease. The Church's objections aren't to the goods themselves, but to specific means she judges incompatible with human dignity.

During COVID, millions of Catholics watched Mass on a screen instead of attending in person. Whether that ever fulfilled the Sunday obligation turns on a distinction most livestreams never explained.

The Church has never resolved how grace and free will fit together — but she has been unambiguous that grace is never a wage owed for enough faith or effort, which is exactly what the prosperity gospel gets wrong.

Von Balthasar's famous question split Catholic theology between those who see it as a legitimate hope and those who see it as a dangerous softening of a hard truth Scripture and tradition insist on.

Mythicism gets outsized attention online. Mainstream secular scholarship — including its most skeptical voices — treats Jesus's existence as one of the least contested facts in ancient history.

The Church has no quarrel with evolutionary biology as such — and Laudato Si' has drawn fire from both sides of the environmental debate for saying so with consequences attached.

The Big Bang, quantum vacuum fluctuations, and multiverse theory are often said to have retired Aquinas's argument from causality. The argument being retired usually isn't the one Aquinas actually made.